Austin Harrouff, former FSU scholar charged in 2 deaths, to be tried in entrance of decide, no jury

STUART – The case in opposition to Austin Harrouff, charged within the 2016 slayings of two folks and the tried homicide of one other, is anticipated to be heard in a non-jury setting that will final three weeks.

The settlement in Circuit Decide Sherwood Bauer’s courtroom got here Tuesday afternoon throughout a listening to relating to whether or not a witness for the state in opposition to Harrouff, charged within the deaths of John Stevens III, 59, and Michelle Mishcon, 53, and the assault and damage of neighbor Jeffrey Fisher in August 2016, can be allowed.

Protection legal professional Bob Watson, who sat with Harrouff, mentioned there was an settlement to a non-jury trial, and to droop the continuing listening to involving Tampa neuropsychologist Michael Gamache to that non-jury trial.

Trial for former FSU scholar: Trial for Austin Harrouff, accused of killing Tequesta couple in 2016, nonetheless months away

State skilled: Austin Harrouff not insane after they killed Tequesta couple

Austin Harrouff court docket paperwork: Homicide suspect Austin Harrouff tells Martin deputies he ‘ate people’

Assistant State Lawyer Anastasia Norman mentioned she thought three weeks can be sufficient for the trial, and Bauer scheduled Nov. 28 via Dec. 16 with a Sept. 28 standing listening to.

Watson and protection legal professional Nellie L. King declined remark after court docket, as did Norman and prosecutor Brandon White.

Harrouff – who was then 19 and attending Florida State College – was discovered biting and chewing on Stevens’ face within the driveway of the couple’s residence on Southeast Kokomo Lane in southern Martin County.

Circuit Decide Sherwood Bauer (far proper), listens June 21, 2022, throughout a listening to within the Austin Harrouff case. Seated in entrance are prosecutors Anastasia Norman (far left) and Brandon White.

Protection attorneys signaled shortly after Harrouff’s arrest they might search an acquittal by motive of madness.

Two psychologists – one employed by the protection and one for the state – have concluded Harrouff was struggling an “acute psychotic episode” when he attacked and killed Mishcon and Stevens III throughout an unprovoked assault.

Each specialists, scientific psychologist Gregory Landrum and Dr. Phillip Resnick, discovered Harrouff was “unable to differentiate proper from incorrect,” that means he meets Florida’s standards to be acquired by motive of madness.

Gamache final 12 months concluded Harrouff did not meet the authorized commonplace of madness.

Gamache Tuesday was grilled by Lawyer Dorothy Clay Sims, each talking through video convention.

Austin Harrouff Protection Psychiatrist: Suspect in face-biting deaths did not know the conduct was incorrect

State psychologist: Austin Harrouff legally insane when he murdered a Tequesta couple in 2016

Below questioning by Sims, Gamache mentioned they did not make a prognosis. He mentioned he was speaking “chances.”

“I’m advising the state as a possible rebuttal skilled, and I’m telling them on this report, that primarily based on the totality of the proof… he mentioned. “I don’t know, and I could by no means know, and I don’t suppose another skilled is aware of for sure. It is about chances. ”

Bauer needed clarification, and Gamache once more mentioned he did not make a prognosis.

“I’m merely describing the probabilities,” Gamache mentioned.

Sims questioned Gamache in quite a lot of areas, together with Harrouff’s therapies and self-reporting of his emotions and feelings in jail.

Gamache mentioned he wasn’t being vital of Landrum, employed by the state, and Resnick, a forensic psychiatrist who issued a report for the protection.

“There is not any rule that claims I’ve to make my very own prognosis, versus differentiating for the advantage of the state what the probabilities are in order that they will ponder learn how to proceed,” Gamache mentioned.

Watson earlier questioned protection witness Dr. Jimmy Valentine, a retired professor who acquired he consults in medical pharmacology and forensic toxicology, relating to 15 medicines that Gamache mentioned “might have been in play.”

Bauer requested for clarification.

“He has 15 various things that he says may both have been acute, persistent or withdrawal from inflicting the substance abuse psychosis,” Watson mentioned.

Nonetheless, beneath questioning from Watson, Valentine mentioned no lab report discovered proof of something in addition to alcohol and THC, the principle psychoactive compound in marijuana.

Will Greenlee can be the breaking information reporter for TCPalm. Comply with Will on Twitter @OffTheBeatTweet or attain him by telephone at 772-267-7926. Electronic mail him at

In case you’re a subscriber, thanks. If not, develop into a subscriber to get the most recent breaking information and crime protection.

This text initially appeared on Treasure Coast Newspapers: Austin Harrouff trial: Former FSU scholar to be tried with out jury

Leave a Comment