Within the first press convention after Russell Wilson was traded, Pete Carroll went on an insanely lengthy spiel about “second probabilities” and the Seattle Seahawks‘workforce philosophy. Geno Smith was even cited as a kind of examples of a second probability participant.
For all we all know, Geno is perhaps the brand new beginning quarterback of the Seahawks, a whopping eight years faraway from the final time he was QB1. If that’s the case, then it’s becoming for a workforce that has had an totally weird fixation with one of many worst draft lessons in current historical past.
The 2013 NFL Draft was dangerous, dangerous, dangerous. Whichever workforce govt mentioned this was the worst draft in a decade within the lead-up to it was on the cash. The Seahawks ’personal class of 2013 was horrible even by the requirements of that 12 months’s Draft. Luke Willson was far and away one of the best decide on the idea of really being on the workforce for greater than a few years, which might’t be mentioned for most of the relaxation.
However that hasn’t stopped the Seahawks from making an attempt to squeeze out one thing out of this specific class years after the very fact! That is simply from the highest two rounds.
Luke Joeckel – No. 2 total
Touted as probably the greatest offensive tackles popping out of school, Joeckel was something however that with the Jacksonville Jaguars. He was moved to left guard in 2016, signed a daft $ 7 million contract with the Seahawks in 2017 and I believe you know the way this catastrophe performed out. Joeckel by no means performed one other NFL down after his one 12 months in Seattle.
Dion Jordan – No. 3 total
A star at Oregon, Jordan’s profession within the NFL was marred by accidents, in addition to a number of suspensions for violating the league’s PED coverage. He solely had three sacks in 26 video games with the Miami Dolphins, then didn’t play in any respect in 2015 or 2016. Jordan was signed by Seattle in 2017 and in solely 5 video games he recorded 4 sacks and confirmed some promise that made him such a excessive draft decide. Dion stayed on board for a second season however by no means elevated himself above rotational piece and wasn’t re-signed after 2018.
Ziggy Ansah – No. 5 total
In contrast to most of the different gamers on right here, Ansah wasn’t a bust when he was with the Detroit Lions. In 2015 he was second-team All-Professional after racking up a career-high 14.5 sacks, and two years earlier than he signed with the Seahawks he had 12.5 sacks. His 2019 with the Seahawks was a complete catastrophe and he’s out of the league. I refuse to consider he truly had 2.5 sacks as a result of that feels method too excessive.
Barkevious Mingo – No. 6 total
In addition to having a beautiful first title, Mingo was one of many key members of a stacked LSU protection that included Tyrann Mathieu, Kevin Minter, and Eric Reid. He was a kind of nice athletes whose potential was that of an elite go rusher. Mingo wasn’t an elite go rusher and efforts to maneuver him to inside linebacker did not work out nicely, both. His one season in Seattle noticed him put up profession highs in tackles and however in any other case he was hardly exceptional (a PFF grade of 55) and the Seahawks traded him to the Houston Texans as a part of the Jadeveon Clowney deal. He is out of the league, and whereas his case was dismissed, this was why.
Likelihood Warmack – No. 10 total
Among the finest guard prospects out of Alabama, Warmack did not constantly stay as much as the billing constantly in Tennessee. After a few years as a reserve depth in Philadelphia, Warmack signed with the Seahawks in 2020 and by no means performed a down. He opted out because of COVID issues in 2020 and was launched in 2021, and stays out of soccer.
DJ Fluker – No. 11 total
Fluker was initially a proper sort out with the San Diego Chargers and made PFWA’s All-Rookie Group. He was moved to the appropriate guard, the place he was the Seahawks’ starter for 2 seasons from 2018-2019. For the time being he’s a free agent after the Jacksonville Jaguars minimize him free from the observe squad in 2021. I believed he was alright however PFF disagreed and graded him a 56 in 2018 (69th of 86 guards) and 60 in 2019 (fiftieth of 90 guards).
Jamar Taylor – No. 54 total
Good grief I did not even do not forget that he was picked this excessive. The Miami Dolphins drafted him and by 2015 he was benched for poor play. He was traded to Cleveland in 2016 after which dealt to Arizona in 2018. When Justin Coleman left, Seattle famously made a meal out of the slot nook place and Taylor was the starter in 2019. He was terribly horrible and was minimize midseason for Ugo Amadi . Taylor spent a 12 months with the 49ers however went on IR in 2020 and hasn’t performed since.
Eddie Lacy – No. 61 total
I’ve not included Sheldon Richardson (thirteenth total), who was Defensive Rookie of the 12 months with the New York Jets and a 2014 Professional Bowl choice, as he was acquired by way of commerce in what was a contract 12 months for Richardson and an act of desperation from Seattle after the Malik McDowell ATV crash. Richardson wasn’t a declare venture or a “second probability” signing just like the others. Marquise Goodwin would not rely both since he was drafted halfway via Spherical 3 and I solely targeted on the highest two rounds.
After which we’ve got Geno Smith. He was the thirty ninth participant taken however solely the second quarterback off the board behind EJ Manuel. His tenure with the New York Jets included a staggering turnover downside, and an damage attributable to teammate IK Enemkpali punching him within the face. Smith misplaced his job, then had an ACL tear the next season, and you recognize the remainder of the story. Geno did not do too badly in his three begins final 12 months, however there’s nothing about his recreation to counsel he is a long-term answer at quarterback. Can he be a stopgap QB in the identical method Tarvaris Jackson was? I suppose so, however that is about it.
However the principle theme of this text is the Seahawks and their unending fascination with such a poor draft class. Each participant I’ve listed above besides Ansah was thought of a bust to a point – sure, together with Fluker. And when Ansah was signed by Seattle he was coming off an injury-riddled 2018 that was a precursor to his speedy decline as a participant. Lacy won’t have been a standard bust given how his profession started in Inexperienced Bay, however he was a reclamation venture simply to get him on weight once more.
Pete Carroll loves particular person reclamation initiatives; Huge Mike Williams was the primary main one in 2010. For that season it labored out above expectation. Their current reclamation efforts – these “low threat, excessive reward” strikes – particularly from that individual 2013 group have been pricey past the cash spent. Seattle’s 2017 offensive line – Joeckel was a starter however as an apart Oday Aboushi was additionally a part of that 2013 class – was legendary horrible and had a serious position within the workforce lacking the playoffs. Eddie Lacy established himself as one of many league’s worst working backs, and whereas he needed to run behind a poor o-line, each Chris Carson and JD McKissic fared a lot better. The Seahawks mainly could not perform out of something however its base protection in 2019 and having a complete legal responsibility in Taylor at nickel was a kind of components. That very same protection could not generate a constant go rush – Ansah was presupposed to be a kind of contributors – and was one of many league’s worst at stopping the run.
Geno is a really completely different story. He is been on the workforce for 3 seasons and is supposedly the frontrunner to be Seattle’s Week 1 starter in 2022, at a time when Carroll insists they’re making an attempt to construct a championship workforce proper now. These different gamers talked about have been both rotational items or starters for a majority of their careers aka getting common enjoying time. Seattle’s quick substitute for his or her best ever quarterback might be a man whose final full season as a starter noticed him win solely 3 video games out of 13 and rank close to the underside throughout the board in superior metrics. His chief competitor is actually on the precipice of bust on the very least, however there’s presupposed to be upside with Drew Lock.
And but I would not be stunned if Geno is the man. Perhaps he can defy the chances and present appreciable enchancment from his Jets days. It might be the holy grail of profession turnarounds if Geno may even be common for an entire season. However we have seen this film earlier than with the Seahawks and particularly this draft class, and I can not shake off that current Seahawks offseason choices have constantly given this vibe: